Ethical issues are becoming increasingly important in ethnographic
research – you will need to consider a range of ethical problems before you
start your research, as you are conducting it and after you have completed it.
Here are a few things to think about:
*
A presentation on ethics
in ethnographic research:
*
An example of an ethical
protocol for
research:
Codes of ethics:
For Social Science Researchers:
–
British Sociological Association ‘Statement of
Ethical Principles and their Application to Sociological Research’
–
A site devoted to various statements and codes for Sociology ethics can
be found here
–
British Psychological Society ‘Ethical principles for Conducting
research with Human Participants’
Some papers on ethics:
* Emancipation
or ... Hanging around doesn't mean sitting on the fence! By Magnus Ramage.
"I have been considering the
question of the extent to which ethnographers should intervene in their
situations of study at some length through the past year. This has principally
arisen from a collision between my a priori assumption that it is the duty of
those with power to work towards the emancipation - or empowerment, though that
word has become debased due to over-use by management consultants - of those
without; and the views of ethnomethodology, which holds that such intervention
is inappropriate".
* Galilean
Nemesis:Notes on Video Ethics in HCI - by Bob Anderson
"These reflections were
originally stimulated by the brouhaha that followed the introduction of video
data into HCI's research methods in the late 1980s and early 1990s and have
lain mouldering in my filing cabinet ever since. When I look at them now, I see
that the same order of consideration could well be offered to illuminate or
give pause for thought to many current research endeavours associated with
investigations of collaborative tools and technologies such as multi-user
agents, recommender systems and of course knowledge management systems. They
too traffic in personal information which is not so much given as 'given off'.
So in the hope that its arguments remain fresh and lively, I have rescued this
Note from the oblivion which would otherwise have been its fate".
* The
Ethics of Research into Invasive Technologies -
by Bob Anderson
"A number of systems which have
been designed to enhance the computational support for collaborative work have
features which are or might be potentially invasive. This has led to a debate
within the domain of CSCW concerned with the ethics of research into such
systems. In this paper, one general species of argument, used both to support
and deny the validity of this research, known as "consequentialism"
is examined. Several variations of consequentialism are examined: pure utility
arguments, superogatory arguments, and Trojan Horse arguments. None is found to
be especially well suited for the structure of the arguments which need to be
deployed. It is concluded that the search for a consequentialist path through
the ethical maze may itself be an unfruitful line of enquiry and indeed the
consequence itself of our over-focus on the technology of argument".
* Privacy
Related Issues In Computer Mediated Spaces by Liam Bannon
"Coming
to terms with an environment that potentially contains active, listening
agents, where images, sounds, texts, gestures are all potentially capturable
and reproducible over time and space creates the need for a new way of thinking
about the whole conception of Privacy than the classic image of somebody
breaking into one’s files, snooping over your shoulder, or listening in on your
phone calls".
Other
ethics websites:
– European Group on
Ethics in Science and New Technologies
– http://europa.eu.int/comm/european_group_ethics/index_en.htm
Any comments or contributions? email us